US clashes with UK on flip clauses

Nicholas Pettifer | NEWS ANALYSIS - February 04, 2010


A US bankruptcy court has ruled that flip clauses are unenforceable. Securitisations could leave the US and ratings agencies may have to change existing structures

A US bankruptcy court has ruled that flip clauses are unenforceable – opposing a decision in the UK. This could lead to securitisations migrating from the US and ratings agencies revisiting existing structures.

In the decision, the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York favoured Lehman Brothers regarding flip clauses in collateralised debt obligations (CDOs). This goes against an earlier decision in the English Court of Appeal.

“This was unexpected. People will have to rethink the way they document things,” said Fredric Sosnick, partner at Shearman & Sterling in New York. “It will be difficult to get similar economics into a structure without having a flip at the parent filing. It’s...




The regulators haven’t mitigated counterparty risk yet, just changed it

Simon Dodds, general counsel at Deutsche Bank, on forcing derivatives through central counterparties

Web seminars

US and EU hybrid capital
February 3 2010
The future of hybrids, in a popular discussion between IFLR, Morrison & Foerster and Calyon

Latest Issue

March 2010

Basel III: The revenge of Basel
New Basel rules are affecting everyone differently. In the UK banks are worried about grandfathering, in Germany the headache is hybrids and in the US it's risk structures. Meanwhile Japan has some tips and Hong Kong structured its first hybrid [more]